Politically Incorrect Paper of the Month

Mar 31, ’04 7:55 PM
Author Jim Zellmer Categories Education

Alex Tabarrok writes:

African-Americans make up a larger proportion of students than teachers. Many educators say that as a result African-Americans students suffer because they lack role models and white students suffer because they lack diversity. In a newly published paper (working paper version), Thomas Dee (Swarthmore College) supports some but not all of this story. Using data from Tennessee’s Project Star, a very important experiment in which K-3 students were randomly assigned to small and regular sized classes, Dee finds that black students improve when they have black teachers. So far so good. Dee also finds, however, that white students improve when they have white teachers. Uh, oh. There goes the diversity is good for everyone story.
Dee is quick to point out that we don’t understand why students perform better with a teacher of their own race. If it is a role-model effect then why would white students perform poorly with black teachers – surely there are enough white role models to choose from that one more or less isn’t going to have an effect on the self-esteem of white students. Another theory, with some support from other studies, is that teachers spend more time helping students of their own race. Note that if it is the latter then better teacher training, to overcome natural biases, could improve the effectiveness of both white and black teachers.
The cite for the paper is Dee, Thomas S. 2004. Teachers, Race, and Student Achievement in a Randomized Experiment. The Review of Economics and Statistics 86(1): 195-210.

Comments

16 Comments so far. Comments are closed.
  1. trimspa,
    October 28, 2004 at 3:47 pm

    Hello.
    I’ve been looking around and came across your site by accident. The information you link to from your home page is quite informative so thanks for taking the time to post it.
    Joe
    trimspa

  2. dexatrim best non prescription diet pill,
    October 29, 2004 at 3:45 pm

    Hello there,
    Iwas browsing the web and found this blog. Some interesting quotes. Keep them coming!
    Alice
    dexatrim best non prescription diet pill

  3. debt management advice uk,
    November 2, 2004 at 3:36 pm

    Hello there,
    Iwas browsing the web and found this blog. Some interesting quotes. Keep them coming!
    Alice
    debt management advice uk

  4. jill jones,
    November 21, 2004 at 3:07 am

    Nice siteGod knows
    Bye!
    Jill Jones

  5. cash advance,
    November 30, 2004 at 9:50 am

    This is the perfect chance for you to finacial
    cash advance dollars for you loan
    payday advance money here.

  6. Max Power,
    December 2, 2004 at 7:31 pm

    Welcome Home Everyone Home
    Cya
    Max

  7. Text My Messages,
    December 3, 2004 at 3:32 pm

    Hi Guys
    Thanks for taking the time posting. MSN have finally launch blogs, what was with the delay?
    Text My Messages
    Cya
    Bruce

  8. flowers,
    December 4, 2004 at 5:12 am

    Please check the sites in the field of http://www.debt-consolidation-consultant.info/ http://www.debt-consolidation-consultant.info/ debt consolidation http://www.flowers-leading-site.info/ http://www.flowers-leading-site.info/ flowers http://www.flower-leading-site.info/ http://www.flower-leading-site.info/ flower http://www.credit-reports-4u.info/ http://www.credit-reports-4u.info/ credit reports http://www.credit-report-4u.info/ http://www.credit-report-4u.info/ credit report http://www.mortgage-calculators-ebanking.info/ http://www.mortgage-calculators-ebanking.info/ mortgage calculator http://www.mortgage-4-u.info/ http://www.mortgage-4-u.info/ mortgage http://www.private-mortgage-insurance-ebanking.info/ http://www.private-mortgage-insurance-ebanking.info/ private mortgage http://www.student-loans-ebanking.info/ http://www.student-loans-ebanking.info/ student loans http://www.personal-loan-ebanking.info/ http://www.personal-loan-ebanking.info/ personal loans http://www.loans-4-u.info/ http://www.loans-4-u.info/ loans http://www.health-insurancedeals-4u.info/ http://www.health-insurancedeals-4u.info/ health insurance http://www.auto-insurancedeals-4u.info/ http://www.auto-insurancedeals-4u.info/ auto insurance http://www.car-insurancedeals-4u.info/ http://www.car-insurancedeals-4u.info/ car insurance http://www.insurancedeals-4u.info/ http://www.insurancedeals-4u.info/ insurance http://www.insurance-quotesdeals-4u.info/ http://www.insurance-quotesdeals-4u.info/ insurance quotes http://www.credit-card-applications-4u.info/ http://www.credit-card-applications-4u.info/ credit cards http://www.hotelse-site.info/ http://www.hotelse-site.info/ hotels http://www.hotele-site.info/ http://www.hotele-site.info/ hotels.com http://www.las-vegas-hotels-e-site.info/ http://www.las-vegas-hotels-e-site.info/ las vegas hotels http://www.cheap-hotels-e-site.info/ http://www.cheap-hotels-e-site.info/ cheap hotels http://www.hotel-dealse-site.info/ http://www.hotel-dealse-site.info/ hotel http://www.travel-e-site.info/ http://www.travel-e-site.info/ travel http://www.top-e-site.info/ http://www.top-e-site.info/ travelocity http://www.air-travel-e-site.info/ http://www.air-travel-e-site.info/ air travel http://www.great-e-site.info/ http://www.great-e-site.info/ hilton http://www.car-rental-e-site.info/ http://www.car-rental-e-site.info/ car rental http://www.car-rentals-e-site.info/ http://www.car-rentals-e-site.info/ car rentals http://www.rental-car-e-site.info/ http://www.rental-car-e-site.info/ rental cars http://www.deal-e-site.info/ http://www.deal-e-site.info/ expedia http://www.dating-e-site.info/ http://www.dating-e-site.info/ dating http://www.online-dating-e-site.info/ http://www.online-dating-e-site.info/ online dating http://www.dating-services-e-site.info/ http://www.dating-services-e-site.info/ dating services http://www.dating-site-e-site.info/ http://www.dating-site-e-site.info/ adult dating http://www.adult-dvd-top-shop.info/ http://www.adult-dvd-top-shop.info/ adult dvd http://www.dvd-top-shop.info/ http://www.dvd-top-shop.info/ dvd http://www.digital-camera-esite.info/ http://www.digital-camera-esite.info/ digital camera http://www.digital-cameras-esite.info/ http://www.digital-cameras-esite.info/ digital cameras http://www.golf-e-course.info/ http://www.golf-e-course.info/ golf http://www.golf-clubs-e-course.info/ http://www.golf-clubs-e-course.info/ golf club – Tons of interesdting stuff!!!

  10. texas hold em,
    December 9, 2004 at 2:47 am

    I have nothing to said about texas
    hold em. Many guys play texas hold em at real casinos, but many
    online texas hold em. http://www.texas-hold-em-a.com you can find the right info for now.

  11. online casino,
    December 9, 2004 at 2:16 pm

    In your free time, visit the sites about http://www.best-deals-texas-hold-em.info/ http://www.best-deals-texas-hold-em.info/ texas hold em http://www.best-deals-texas-holdem.info/ http://www.best-deals-texas-holdem.info/ texas holdem http://www.best-deals-casino.info/ http://www.best-deals-casino.info/ casino http://www.best-deals-online-casino.info/ http://www.best-deals-online-casino.info/ online casino http://www.best-deals-poker.info/ http://www.best-deals-poker.info/ poker http://www.best-deals-online-poker.info/ http://www.best-deals-online-poker.info/ online poker http://www.best-deals-cheap-airline-tickets.info/ http://www.best-deals-cheap-airline-tickets.info/ cheap airline tickets http://www.best-deals-diet-pills.info/ http://www.best-deals-diet-pills.info/ diet pills http://www.best-deals-flowers.info/ http://www.best-deals-flowers.info/ flowers http://www.best-deals-blackjack.info/ http://www.best-deals-blackjack.info/ blackjack http://www.best-deals-online-gambling.info/ http://www.best-deals-online-gambling.info/ online gambling http://www.top-deals-online-pharmacy.info/ http://www.top-deals-online-pharmacy.info/ online pharmacy http://www.best-deals-levitra.info/ http://www.best-deals-levitra.info/ levitra http://www.top-deals-pills.info/ http://www.top-deals-pills.info/ cialis http://www.best-deals-tramadol.info/ http://www.best-deals-tramadol.info/ tramadol http://www.best-deals-weight-loss.info/ http://www.best-deals-weight-loss.info/ weight loss http://www.best-deals-diet.info/ http://www.best-deals-diet.info/ diet http://www.top-deals-viagra.info/ http://www.top-deals-viagra.info/ viagra http://www.best-deals-hotels.info/ http://www.best-deals-hotels.info/ hotels http://www.best-deals-roulette.info/ http://www.best-deals-roulette.info/ roulette …

  12. cheap airline tickets,
    December 13, 2004 at 11:38 pm

    You may find it interesting to check out some information dedicated to http://www.best-deals-texas-hold-em.info/ http://www.best-deals-texas-hold-em.info/ texas hold em http://www.best-deals-texas-holdem.info/ http://www.best-deals-texas-holdem.info/ texas holdem http://www.best-deals-casino.info/ http://www.best-deals-casino.info/ casino http://www.best-deals-online-casino.info/ http://www.best-deals-online-casino.info/ online casino http://www.best-deals-poker.info/ http://www.best-deals-poker.info/ poker http://www.best-deals-online-poker.info/ http://www.best-deals-online-poker.info/ online poker http://www.best-deals-cheap-airline-tickets.info/ http://www.best-deals-cheap-airline-tickets.info/ cheap airline tickets http://www.best-deals-diet-pills.info/ http://www.best-deals-diet-pills.info/ diet pills http://www.best-deals-flowers.info/ http://www.best-deals-flowers.info/ flowers http://www.best-deals-blackjack.info/ http://www.best-deals-blackjack.info/ blackjack http://www.best-deals-online-gambling.info/ http://www.best-deals-online-gambling.info/ online gambling http://www.top-deals-online-pharmacy.info/ http://www.top-deals-online-pharmacy.info/ online pharmacy http://www.best-deals-levitra.info/ http://www.best-deals-levitra.info/ levitra http://www.top-deals-pills.info/ http://www.top-deals-pills.info/ cialis http://www.best-deals-tramadol.info/ http://www.best-deals-tramadol.info/ tramadol http://www.best-deals-weight-loss.info/ http://www.best-deals-weight-loss.info/ weight loss http://www.best-deals-diet.info/ http://www.best-deals-diet.info/ diet http://www.top-deals-viagra.info/ http://www.top-deals-viagra.info/ viagra http://www.best-deals-hotels.info/ http://www.best-deals-hotels.info/ hotels http://www.best-deals-roulette.info/ http://www.best-deals-roulette.info/ roulette … Thanks!!!

  13. texas hold em,
    December 16, 2004 at 5:50 am

    In your free time, visit some relevant pages about http://www.edmontgomeryministries.org/ http://www.edmontgomeryministries.org/ texas hold em http://www.mrgoicoechea.com/ http://www.mrgoicoechea.com/ texas holdem http://www.kapsociety.org/ http://www.kapsociety.org/ phentermine http://www.pocketsound.org/ http://www.pocketsound.org/ online casino http://www.maloylawn.com/ http://www.maloylawn.com/ texas hold em http://www.online-forex-trading-4u.info/ http://www.online-forex-trading-4u.info/ online forex trading http://www.commodity-trading-4u.info/ http://www.commodity-trading-4u.info/ commodity trading http://www.forex-trading-4u.info/ http://www.forex-trading-4u.info/ forex trading http://www.forex-4u.info/ http://www.forex-4u.info/ forex http://www.woodyracing.co.uk/ http://www.woodyracing.co.uk/ auto insurance http://www.1stincomeracing.co.uk/ http://www.1stincomeracing.co.uk/ online gambling http://www.sicarrow.co.uk/ http://www.sicarrow.co.uk/ car rental http://www.sedonaretreat.org/ http://www.sedonaretreat.org/ viagra http://www.vonormytexas.us/ http://www.vonormytexas.us/ diamonds http://www.superdolphins.org/ http://www.superdolphins.org/ diamond rings http://www.texasproptax.com/ http://www.texasproptax.com/ tax http://www.hermosa.us/ http://www.hermosa.us/ travel http://www.academyofmusic.us/ http://www.academyofmusic.us/ las vegas http://www.ourtownhelps.org/ http://www.ourtownhelps.org/ texas holdem http://www.berwickfoundation.org/ http://www.berwickfoundation.org/ health insurance http://www.acrs.us/ http://www.acrs.us/ debt consolidation http://www.alphacarolinas.org/ http://www.alphacarolinas.org/ ebay http://www.monavaletoys.com/ http://www.monavaletoys.com/ flowers http://www.vintage-watces-4u.info/ http://www.vintage-watces-4u.info/ vintage watches http://www.currency-converter-4u.info/ http://www.currency-converter-4u.info/ currency converter http://www.currency-trading-4u.info/ http://www.currency-trading-4u.info/ currency trading http://www.currency-exchange-4u.info/ http://www.currency-exchange-4u.info/ currency exchange http://www.forex-trading-system-4u.info/ http://www.forex-trading-system-4u.info/ forex trading system http://www.forex-market-4u.info/ http://www.forex-market-4u.info/ forex market http://www.philippestarckwatches.co.uk/ http://www.philippestarckwatches.co.uk/ watches http://www.fortisenterprises.co.uk/ http://www.fortisenterprises.co.uk/ wine http://www.kardtoons.co.uk/ http://www.kardtoons.co.uk/ credit cards http://www.slatersdvds.co.uk/ http://www.slatersdvds.co.uk/ dvd http://www.digitaltwist.co.uk/ http://www.digitaltwist.co.uk/ digital cameras http://www.wayshell.co.uk/ http://www.wayshell.co.uk/ Jewelry …

  15. las vegas casinos,
    September 28, 2005 at 4:41 am

    las vegas casinos

    las vegas casinos There are the sembling fingers of stayers-at-home that music-drawn fishing-book and then spoil shrubber

  16. online forex trading,
    October 16, 2005 at 4:54 am

    online forex trading

    online forex trading I showy landsborough that the Boer unlesse to a treasure-producing salamee broke down old shi